Order Now

Christmas 2020

Christmas orders are CLOSED

Pre-orders are SOLD OUT.

Extra 6" & 9" pies, hand pie boxes, individual hand pies, 9" quiche, take n bake cinnamon rolls, cookies, quick breads, and pie fries will be available at our Elm Grove Lutheran Church pick up on December 23 between 11am-4pm. All items are first come first serve. No pre-orders and no holds.

Questions prior to pick up? Please call 414-465-9176.

Questions day of pick up? Please call 414-418-5217 (please be respectful and use this number wisely as this is Allison's personal number). 

*****************************************************************************

Pick up available: Wednesday, December 23 - 11:00am-4:00pm

IMPORTANT: December 23 pick up will be held at Elm Grove Lutheran Church (945 Terrace Dr. Elm Grove, WI 53122) rather than our Brookfield kitchen this year to allow for adequate spacing and necessary safety precautions due to COVID-19. Pick up will be run as a drive-thru (no need to exit your vehicle) and all items will be prepackaged with appropriate labeling.

Please read carefully when checking out. Confirmation and reminder emails will be sent 2 days prior to pick up selected, along with specific pick up instructions and maps to locations.

Times chosen are not reflective of a specific time but rather a window of time for pick up - i.e. pick up time 3:00pm means you can pick up between 3:00pm and 4:00pm.

Questions? Email us at info@hatchedmke.com.

Product Name:

Apple Pear Mince (SOLD OUT)

Apple Pear Mince (SOLD OUT)
6" Small Pie

SOLD OUT

A little nostalgia, a true classic – mincemeat for many means it’s time for Christmas and family. We’ve taken a new twist on this classic by adding dried tart Door County cherries, pecans, walnuts, and a good helping of brandy. Perfect for gifting this holiday season!

Only available in 6" size. Perfect for gifting or sharing amongst 2-3 people.

- +
$18.00 0

Product Name:

Caramel Apple

Caramel Apple
6" Small Pie or 9" Whole PieOur award-winning Caramel Apple Pie is filled with local tart apples, cinnamon, and gooey homemade caramel. This pie is then topped with a brown sugar crumb that disguises itself as a delicious oatmeal cookie. Finished off with more gooey caramel, this guy is everything you want and more.
- +
$18.00 0

Product Name:

Champagne Chess (SOLD OUT)

Champagne Chess (SOLD OUT)
9" Whole Pie

SOLD OUT

Filled with house made champagne syrup and adorned with a sugared cranberry and rosemary wreath, this gorgeous little pie is sure to be a showstopper for all of your guests.

Only available in 9" size.

- +
$35.00 0

Product Name:

Cranberry Cherry

Cranberry Cherry
6" Small Pie or 9" Whole PieFilled with sweet and tart cherries and studded with ruby cranberries, this seasonal beauty is dressed with a spicy gingerbread crumb and finished with a sweet and simple gingerbread icing.
- +
$18.00 0

Product Name:

Egg Nog Custard

Egg Nog Custard
6" Small Pie or 9" Whole PieSilky, sweet, and full of vanilla and nutmeg, this beauty will be sure to put you in that Christmas spirit.
- +
$18.00 0

Product Name:

Pfeffernüsse

Pfeffernüsse
6" Small Pie or 9" Whole PieInspired by Allison’s great grandmother’s German molasses cookies, our Pfeffernüsse Pie is richly spiced with cardamom, ginger, and cinnamon and finished with a dusting of powdered sugar.
- +
$18.00 0

Product Name:

Southern Pecan

Southern Pecan
6" Small Pie or 9" Whole Pie

Pretty in pecans! Caramel-like filling with a touch of molasses and finished with whole pecans, this pretty girl will be sure to make you smile.

Gluten Free Friendly option only available in 9" size.

- +
$18.00 0

Product Name:

Winter Hand Pies

Winter Hand Pies
Hand Pies

Choose from 3 festive hand pie boxes for your holiday celebrations!

*SOLD OUT* Variety: Apple Cinnamon, Cranberry Cherry, Spiced Pear & Persimmon, and Peppermint Chocolate

*SOLD OUT* Blueberry Lemon Curd: four hand pies of our most popular flavor

*SOLD OUT* Sugar Plum: four hand pies filled with spiced plums and wrapped in our flaky dough. This holiday classic is topped with a decadent vanilla brandy icing for that extra festive flair.

*SOLD OUT* Gluten Free (Friendly) Variety: Sugar Plum, Cranberry Cherry, Spiced Pear & Persimmon, and Peppermint Chocolate (Limited quantities)

- +
$20.00 0

Product Name:

Quick Bread

Quick Bread
Bread

A simple and tasty addition to make Christmas morning 100% easier!

Grandma's Banana Bread: A few bananas, a sprinkling of walnuts, and a whole lot of love! This banana bread is straight from my childhood. Every time we had extra bananas lying around, my mom would pull out her mother's recipe for this super simple but oh so delicious banana bread. *Contains walnuts. Also, 100% dairy free!

*SOLD OUT* Gingerbread: Loaded with all that Christmas spice, this bread will surely put you in the mood for a Christmas movie or two and a cup of hot cocoa! Pro tip: ask to add a container of cream cheese icing at pick up. You won't regret it, just saying.

- +
$15.00 0

Product Name:

DIY Christmas Cookie Box

DIY Christmas Cookie Box
Cookies

Santa could always use a couple extra cookies! Keep those little hands busy with our DIY cookie box and make some memories while you're at it!

Contains: 12 festive sugar cookies, 3 piping bags of icing, and sprinkles!

P.S. This is the same sugar cookie recipe I made as a child with my family. Thanks for helping me relive my childhood one cookie box at a time!

- +
$27.00 0

Product Name:

Take n Bake Cinnamon Rolls (SOLD OUT)

Take n Bake Cinnamon Rolls (SOLD OUT)
Cinnamon Rolls

SOLD OUT

Your favorite weekend cinnamon rolls are now ready to be baked at home!

5-pack Cinnamon Rolls come fully frozen with thawing, proofing, and baking instructions. Cream cheese icing included on the side for making Christmas morning extra special.

- +
$20.00 0