Order Now

Christmas 2021

**Christmas EXTRAS**

Last minute Christmas orders will open on TUESDAY, December 21 at 8:00am and will remain open until sold out. No extras will be available for purchase at the time of pick up. If you want extra goodies, you must order online. Once an item is listed as SOLD OUT, it is completely sold out and is no longer available.

Pick up: Thursday, December 23 - 12:00pm-5:00pm

IMPORTANT: Pick up will be held at our Brookfield kitchen (655 N Brookfield Rd.). Upon arrival at our kitchen, please call us and we will bring your order to your vehicle. Customers will not be allowed in our kitchen.

Upon arrival, follow the signs and the instructions of our volunteers. *Please take the driveway on the southern side of our building to the back parking lot. We ask that you do not park, but instead stay in line to keep our pick-ups moving quickly. Please remain in your vehicle. Orders will be delivered directly to your vehicle. If you’d prefer no contact, please be prepared to open your trunk or back door. All vehicles will exit at the driveway to the north of our building.

We are collecting children’s books again this year for Ronald McDonald House Charities-Easter Wisconsin. Board books and young children’s books are so appreciated, but all books are welcome. *RMHC families’ needs include toys and books for all ages, genders, and backgrounds. Diverse, multi-lingual and non-violent toys are appreciated. Thank you for your generosity!

We are not offering specific pick up times but rather a window of time for pick up. Any pies not claimed by 5:00pm will be donated.

Questions? Email us at info@hatchedmke.com.

Product Name:

Apple Pear Mince

Apple Pear Mince
6" Small Pie

A little nostalgia, a true classic – mincemeat for many means it’s time for Christmas and family. We’ve taken a new twist on this classic by adding dried tart Door County cherries, pecans, walnuts, and a good helping of brandy. Perfect for gifting this holiday season!

Only available in 6" size. Perfect for gifting or sharing amongst 2-3 people.

*Allergens: wheat, milk, eggs, nuts

Storage: Room temperature/countertop for up to 2 days; extend shelf life by refrigerating up to 5 days

- +
$20.00 0

Product Name:

Caramel Apple

Caramel Apple
6" Small Pie or 9" Whole Pie

SOLD OUT

Our award-winning Caramel Apple Pie is filled with local tart apples, cinnamon, and gooey homemade caramel. This pie is then topped with a brown sugar crumb that disguises itself as a delicious oatmeal cookie. Finished off with more gooey caramel, this guy is everything you want and more.

*Allergens: wheat, egg, dairy

Storage: Room temperature/countertop for up to 2 days; extend shelf life by refrigerating up to 5 days

- +
$18.00 0

Product Name:

Champagne Chess

Champagne Chess
9" Whole Pie

Filled with house made champagne syrup and adorned with a sugared cranberry and rosemary wreath, this gorgeous little pie is sure to be a showstopper for all of your guests.

Only available in 9" size.

*Allergens: wheat, milk, eggs

Storage: Refrigerate up to 4 days.

- +
$37.00 0

Product Name:

Cranberry Cherry

Cranberry Cherry
6" Small Pie or 9" Whole Pie

SOLD OUT

Filled with sweet and tart cherries and studded with ruby cranberries, this seasonal beauty is dressed with a spicy gingerbread crumb and finished with a sweet and simple gingerbread icing.

*Allergens: wheat, eggs

Storage: Room temperature/countertop for up to 2 days; extend shelf life by refrigerating up to 5 days. Refresh your pie by reheating at 350F for 15-20 min, or until warm.

- +
$18.00 0

Product Name:

Egg Nog Custard

Egg Nog Custard
6" Small Pie or 9" Whole Pie

Silky, sweet, and full of vanilla and nutmeg, this beauty will be sure to put you in that Christmas spirit.

*Allergens: wheat, milk, eggs

Storage: Refrigerate up to 4 days.

- +
$18.00 0

Product Name:

Pfeffernüsse

Pfeffernüsse
6" Small Pie or 9" Whole Pie

Inspired by Allison’s great grandmother’s German molasses cookies, our Pfeffernüsse Pie is richly spiced with cardamom, ginger, and cinnamon and finished with a dusting of powdered sugar.

*Allergens: wheat, milk, eggs

Storage: Room temperature/countertop for up to 2 days; extend shelf life by refrigerating up to 1 week

- +
$18.00 0

Product Name:

Southern Pecan

Southern Pecan
6" Small Pie or 9" Whole Pie

Pretty in pecans! Caramel-like filling with a touch of molasses and finished with whole pecans, this pretty girl will be sure to make you smile.

*Allergens: wheat, egg, nuts, dairy

Storage: Room temperature/countertop for up to 2 days; extend shelf life by refrigerating up to 1 week

- +
$18.00 0

Product Name:

Quiche

Quiche
6" or 9" Quiche

The perfect accompaniment to your brunch table!

Bacon Cheddar Potato: Wisconsin cheddar, crumbled bacon, and house seasoned roasted potatoes

Spinach Feta: crumbled feta cheese, green onions, and spinach

*Allergens: wheat, eggs, dairy

Fully baked quiche comes refrigerated with reheating instructions. 9" quiche serves 6-8. 6" quiche serves 2-3. Refrigerate for up to 4 days.

- +
$18.00 0

Product Name:

Winter Hand Pies

Winter Hand Pies
Hand Pies

SOLD OUT

Choose from 4 festive hand pie boxes for your holiday celebrations!

Variety: Apple Cinnamon, Cranberry Cherry, Spiced Pear & Persimmon, and Peppermint Chocolate

Blueberry Lemon Curd: four hand pies of our most popular flavor

Gluten Free (Friendly) Variety: Blueberry Lemon Curd, Cranberry Cherry, Spiced Pear & Persimmon, and Peppermint Chocolate (Limited quantities)

Mini Variety: Same flavors as our regular variety box, but smaller hand pies! Perfect for sampling multiple flavors or sharing with family. Mini hand pies are approximately half the size of our regular hand pies. 3 of each flavor in each box; 12 mini hand pies total.

*Allergens: wheat, milk, eggs, nuts, soy

Storage: Room temperature/countertop for up to 2 days; extend shelf life by refrigerating up to 4 days

- +
$24.00 0

Product Name:

Quick Bread

Quick Bread
Bread

 *Slices only*

Choose from either our decadent Carrot Cake or bright Lemon Poppy Seed slice! 

Storage: Room temperature/countertop for up to 2 days; extend shelf life by refrigerating up to 1 week or freeze up to 3-4 months

**Allergens: Carrot cake is dairy free, but contains walnuts, wheat, and eggs. Lemon Poppy Seed contains wheat, dairy, and eggs.

- +
$5.00 0

Product Name:

DIY Christmas Cookie Box

DIY Christmas Cookie Box
Cookies

SOLD OUT

Santa could always use a couple extra cookies! Keep those little hands busy with our DIY cookie box and make some memories while you're at it!

Contains: 12 festive sugar cookies, 3 piping bags of icing, and sprinkles!

P.S. This is the same sugar cookie recipe I made as a child with my family. Thanks for helping me relive my childhood one cookie box at a time!

*Allergens: wheat, eggs, dairy, almond (extract)

- +
$30.00 0

Product Name:

Cream Cheese Icing

Cream Cheese Icing
Special

SOLD OUT

Over 1/2 lb of that creamy dreamy icing that pairs perfectly with our Gingerbread or Spiced Pumpkin Loaf!

- +
$4.00 0

Product Name:

Cookies

Cookies
Cookies

SOLD OUT

Cookies and milk for Santa!

Mini Variety Box: 3 of each flavor (Chocolate Chip, Confetti, Cranberry Pistachio, Molasses, Peppermint Chocolate, Snickerdoodle) for a total of 18 smaller (2.5 inch) cookies!

*Allergens: wheat, eggs, dairy, nuts (Cranberry Pistachio only)

- +
$30.00 0

Product Name:

Take n Bake Cinnamon Rolls

Take n Bake Cinnamon Rolls
Cinnamon Rolls

SOLD OUT 
Easter brunch wouldn't be complete without a few cinnamon swirls! Only available as a frozen 5-pack. All cinnamon rolls come with dreamy cream cheese icing to top those sweet rolls after baking!

1. Leaving the plastic wrap on the pan, thaw rolls in refrigerator for 12-14 hours. Remove from refrigerator and, with plastic wrap on, let rolls proof in a warm (not hot) place for 60-90 minutes until almost double in size.

2. Preheat oven to 350F. Position oven rack to the bottom of the oven. Remove plastic wrap and brush rolls with heavy cream. Place pan on a baking sheet.  Bake for 25-27 mins, rotating after 13 minutes. Enjoy with cream cheese icing.

*Allergens: wheat, eggs, dairy

- +
$28.00 0

Product Name:

Granola

Granola
Granola

Cranberry Almond: Toasty oats with a touch of cinnamon and vanilla make this the perfect breakfast treat! We added whole almonds for that extra crunch and tart dried cranberries balance out this wholesome snack.

Chocolate Raspberry:  Our classic toasty granola packed with cocoa, brown sugar, chocolate chunks, whole almonds, and a bright raspberry chocolate punch! You'll be snacking on this weekend treat all hours of the day.

Weight: 1lb; store at room temperature for up to 2 weeks.

*Allergens: eggs, nuts

- +
$16.00 0

Product Name:

Hatched Beanie

Hatched Beanie
Merchandise

Crafted by Wisconsin native, Knitted What-Knot, these beanies are the perfect addition to your winter wardrobe!

Purchases of merchandise help us keep the lights on during the slower months of winter. Thank you for supporting our small business!

- +
$30.00 0