Order Now

Thanksgiving 2020

Thanksgiving orders are now CLOSED!

Pre-orders are SOLD OUT.

Extra 6" & 9" pies, hand pie boxes, individual hand pies, frozen savory 2-packs (single flavor), and pie fries will be available at our Elm Grove Lutheran Church pick up on November 25 between 11am-5pm. All items are first come first serve. No pre-orders and no holds.

Questions prior to pick up? Please call 414-465-9176.

Questions day of pick up? Please call 414-418-5217 (please be respectful and use this number wisely as this is Allison's personal number). 


 *******************************************************************

Pick up available: Wednesday, November 25 - 11:00am-5:00pm and Thursday, November 26 - 9:00am-12:00pm

IMPORTANT: Thanksgiving Eve (11/25) pick up will be held at Elm Grove Lutheran Church (945 Terrace Dr. Elm Grove, WI 53122) rather than our Brookfield kitchen this year to allow for adequate spacing and necessary safety precautions due to COVID-19. Pick up will be run as a drive-thru (no need to exit your vehicle) and all items will be prepackaged with appropriate labeling.

Please read carefully when checking out. Confirmation and reminder emails will be sent 2 days prior to pick up selected, along with specific pick up instructions and maps to locations.

Times chosen are not reflective of a specific time but rather a window of time for pick up - i.e. pick up time 4:00pm means you can pick up between 4:00pm and 5:00pm.

Questions? Email us at info@hatchedmke.com.

Product Name:

Black Bottom Oat

Black Bottom Oat
6" Small Pie or 9" Whole PieLike a giant chocolate chip oatmeal cookie, this pie starts with a rich base of dark chocolate ganache and is then filled with brown sugar and toasted oats. Gooey like a pecan pie, but oh so chocolate-y and chewy!
- +
$18.00 0

Product Name:

Caramel Apple

Caramel Apple
6" Small Pie or 9" Whole PieOur award-winning Caramel Apple Pie is filled with local tart apples, cinnamon, and gooey homemade caramel. This pie is then topped with a brown sugar crumb that disguises itself as a delicious oatmeal cookie. Finished off with more gooey caramel, this guy is everything you want and more.
- +
$18.00 0

Product Name:

Classic Apple

Classic Apple
9" Whole PieSweet and simple! This classic is full of tart apples, brown sugar, and cinnamon, then enveloped in a cinnamon sugar cased crust.
- +
$30.00 0

Product Name:

Classic Pumpkin

Classic Pumpkin
6" Small Pie or 9" Whole Pie

This classic pie is thick and custard-y and spiced just right with cinnamon, nutmeg, and cloves. Top this guy with a spoonful (or 4) of fresh whipped cream and your belly will thank you.

Gluten Free Friendly option only available in 9" size.

- +
$18.00 0

Product Name:

Cranberry Cherry

Cranberry Cherry
6" Small Pie or 9" Whole PieFilled with sweet and tart cherries and studded with ruby cranberries, this seasonal beauty is dressed with a spicy gingerbread crumb and finished with a sweet and simple gingerbread icing.
- +
$18.00 0

Product Name:

Pumpkin Praline

Pumpkin Praline
9" Whole PieCreamy cheesecake, spiced pumpkin filling, maple candied pecans, and silky maple whipped cream, this is the ultimate pumpkin pie!
- +
$32.00 0

Product Name:

Salted Brown Butter Honey

Salted Brown Butter Honey
6" Small Pie or 9" Whole PieSweet and salty come together to create the most wonderful balance in our Salted Brown Butter Honey. Filled with local honey and nutty brown butter and finished off with Malden salt flakes.
- +
$18.00 0

Product Name:

Southern Pecan

Southern Pecan
6" Small Pie or 9" Whole Pie

Pretty in pecans! Caramel-like filling with a touch of molasses and finished with whole pecans, this pretty girl will be sure to make you smile.

Gluten Free Friendly option only available in 9" size.

- +
$18.00 0